One tube, five flavours
CF triode (self / fixed / peak-detect) and pentode. What each buys.
Before there's any loop or any reference, there's the pass tube. A single triode (or pentode) in cathode-follower duty filters ripple and presents a low output impedance — without needing a separate Vref. Five wiring variations are catalogued; here's the headline tour.
Grid returned via Rg to ground, cathode resistor Rk sets the bias. Simplest possible. Rout ≈ 1/gm (≈ 50 Ω for a 6080). Ripple drops from 800 mV to ~150 mV. Line reg: poor — ±20 % mains gives ±50 V at Vout.
Self-bias CF triode — V_out, Z_out, P_diss
A triode wired as a cathode follower drops V_ak between anode (at V_raw) and cathode (at V_out), and a further I·Rk on the cathode resistor that auto-biases the grid. The output voltage is simply what is left after both drops.
The grid is grounded through Rg, so the grid-to-cathode bias is simply −I·Rk. To pick Rk you choose the desired bias voltage from the tube’s datasheet:
Open-loop output impedance
The small-signal Z_out of a CF triode (looking into the cathode, with grid grounded for AC) is the reflected plate resistance r_p/(µ+1). The familiar 1/g_m form is only the µ≫1 approximation of this — fine for high-µ tubes, but it overestimates badly for a low-µ power triode like the 6080 (µ=2).
The 1/g_m form is the µ≫1 approximation — it overestimates here since µ=2. Use the exact r_p/(µ+1) for the 6080:
Pass-tube dissipation
The triode sees V_ak across it and conducts I_load (cathode current ≈ load current at this scale). Multiply for the average anode dissipation.
Ripple attenuation: — a self-bias CF has no error-amplifier loop, so V_raw ripple passes through almost unchanged. The big input filter (LC / CRC) does most of the work.
Grid driven from a divider on Vraw + Cg bypass. No Rk — grid voltage doesn't move with cathode current, so load reg improves. Ripple slightly worse (~200 mV) but Cg dampens it.
Fixed-bias CF triode — V_out, Z_out, bias divider
Same CF topology as the self-bias variant, but the grid is no longer pulled to ground via Rg — instead it is sat at a chosen DC potential. The pass-tube equation is unchanged except R_k is gone.
V_grid can come from a negative bias supply (clean but adds a winding/rectifier), or from a stiff divider on V_raw. In divider form the upper resistor sets the loading and the lower one (R_g) sets the grid voltage:
Why Z_out is (a hair) better
In self-bias the cathode resistor R_k introduces local NFB that raises Z_out by R_k/(1+µ) at low frequencies. Fixed bias removes R_k entirely (or fully bypasses it with a large cap), so only the intrinsic CF impedance remains:
Practically identical to self-bias when Rk is well bypassed — the win is mostly that no Rk dissipates a few watts as heat.
Pass-tube dissipation
Note: the divider taps V_raw, so any V_raw ripple shows up on the grid (and thus on V_out) with full µ. A bypass cap on R_g shunts that ripple to ground above the corner frequency — this is what the Cg in the schematic does.
Adds a D1 diode on the grid drive: Cg charges to the peak of Vraw rather than its average. Lifts the bias and reduces dropout headroom — practical when Vraw is tight.
Peak-detect bias CF — V_grid pinned to V_raw,peak
A series diode + reservoir cap on the grid drive samples the peak of V_raw instead of its DC average. The grid then sits at (V_peak − V_diode), and the cathode follower lands |V_bias| volts below that. Net effect: a few tens of volts of extra V_out headroom when V_raw is barely above what you need.
How long must the cap hold?
Between successive peaks the cap discharges through the bleed resistor R_bleed (plus any grid current). The fractional droop over one ripple period is approximately:
Rule of thumb: keep R·C at least 100× T_ripple to stay under 1 % droop and avoid imposing fresh ripple on V_out.
Same Z_out, same P_diss — only the bias rail moves
Z_out and P_diss are unchanged from the self-bias / fixed-bias formulae — peak detection only redefines V_grid. Effectively, you trade a few volts of average headroom for the peak-minus-diode value.
Ripple atten: — peak detection lifts the operating point but, like the other bias schemes, has no error loop. The grid-cap RC also adds a (slow) HP corner if R_bleed is too small.
Replace the triode with a pentode (EL509, 6L6 in pentode). The high anode impedance gives ~24 dB ripple atten (vs 12 dB for the triode), at the cost of needing a clean screen reference. The "no choke" variant assumes cap-input upstream — same regulator schematic, different PSU.
Pentode CF — high g_m, high r_p, no µ feedback
A pentode in CF duty keeps the same V_out = V_raw − V_ak relation as the triode case, but the screen grid (G2) draws its own current from a separate clean reference. The dissipation budget therefore has two terms, and the small-signal Z_out is much higher because pentodes have essentially no µ-feedback in CF.
Why Z_out is higher than for a triode CF
A pentode acts as a near-ideal current source from anode to cathode — r_p is in the tens of kΩ, and the screen decouples plate voltage from cathode current. In CF, the small-signal output impedance reduces to:
In practice r_p is so high it drops out, leaving 1/g_m in parallel with the actual load impedance. With a high g_m pentode like the EL509 you can get tens of ohms — but the lack of a µ-feedback term means line/load reg is poor without an outer loop:
Total pass-tube dissipation
Two terms — anode and screen. Both must be checked against the tube datasheet maxima (typically P_a,max ≫ P_g2,max).
Note: the screen *must* be referenced to a stable, well-bypassed node (often its own VR tube — 0A2 / 0B2). Any ripple on V_g2 transfers directly to I_a, then to V_out through the cathode resistor of the load.
Pentode CF, cap-input PSU — V_raw,DC ≈ V_peak, ripple budget tight
Removing the input choke gives a cap-input (a.k.a. Π / "pi" if a second cap is added). DC at the reservoir is now near the rectified peak rather than 0.9·V_rms, which is great for headroom — but ripple at the regulator input is several volts peak-to-peak instead of millivolts. The regulator equations are the same as the pentode CF case; the differences live on the PSU side and in how much ripple reaches V_out.
Ripple at the regulator input
Standard full-wave cap-input ripple, in the textbook approximation:
With a 50 Hz mains and a full-wave rectifier, f_ripple = 100 Hz; this puts the ripple in the volts, not millivolts.
Open-loop ripple atten of the pentode CF
The pentode CF, without an outer error loop, has only its g_m·R_load to fight V_raw movement. Ripple at the output is:
Dropout check
The cap-input PSU swings between V_peak and (V_peak − V_ripple,pp). Even the *bottom* of the ripple must keep V_ak above the pentode’s minimum operating value, or the regulator falls out of regulation once per half-cycle:
Note: removing the choke also removes its critical-inductance constraint (no minimum load needed), and is cheaper / lighter. Cost: visible 100 Hz hum on V_out unless you close an error loop or add a CRC stage downstream.